Costco shopper @costco.hotbuys recently spotted a two-pack of the Babe Original Lip Mask marked down to just $9.97, making each jar under $5—a fraction of what you’d pay for the name-brand version.

There is truly nothing else like it on the market,” Senior Social Media Marketing Manager Michelle Moezam raves.

A step up from the original game-changer, these Y2K-core tubed lip oils are tinted with six Juicylicious shades and scents, ...